PDF KINDLE Am I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity É Sharlene Hesse–Biber

  • Paperback
  • 208
  • Am I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity
  • Sharlene Hesse-Biber
  • English
  • 10 March 2020
  • 9780195117912

Sharlene Hesse-Biber º 4 review

Read & Download Ö Am I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity Û PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Summary ´ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook º Sharlene Hesse-Biber Sharlene Hesse-Biber º 4 review H her weight who considers herself a real clod in ballet class because she is not as thin as her peers We are introduced to women and men from different cultures who themselves have acuired eating disorders in pursuit of the American standard of physical perfection And we learn of the often tragic conseuences of this obsession with thinness as in the case of Janet who underwent surgery to reduce her weight only to suffer from chronic illness and pain as a result The book concludes with Hesse Biber's prescriptions on how women can overcome their low self image through therapy spiritualism and grass root efforts to empower themselves against a society obsessed with beauty and thinness Am I Thin Enough Yet brings into sharp focus the multitude of societal and psychological forces that compel American women to pursue the ideal of thinness at any cost It will remain a benchmark work on the subject for many years to come. Borrowing on the success of The Beauty Myth Hesse Biber offers this argument that the socio cultural preoccupation with policing bodies and weight is a cult which we are initiated into from birth Starting in the 1960s it has grown into it s own self actualised being that no longer needs gate keepers to sustain it Her arguments are sound and as with other similar analyses oft uses highly emotional knowledge On the whole the book is an easy read and is light on academic language I read the second edition which was revised and published in 2007 11 years after the first edition It was disappointing to note that although Hesse Biber had updated and re contextualised many of her statistics examples and advertisements in much the same way Jean Kilbourne does in her Killing Us softly lectures she was still using the same early 90s stats zombie stats regarding models and body image Her analysis of Abercrombie and Fitch s inclusiveness or lack thereof seemed outdated There were also moments where her argument seemed to cloud her analysis such as asserting that one s social class is not visible whereas weight is The issue is complex than thisHesse Biber s study that formed the basis for the cultural analysis in the book was also limited to College students Therefore it lacked inclusiveness and re affirmed the notion of thin EDs as a middle upper class issue Although she later attempted to refute this in the book it became the prevailing subcontext and contradicts her above assertionHesse Biber s most interesting distinction in the book is between culturally induced eating disorders and psychologically induced eating disorders Although the two can merge or be indistinguishable the former is driven by a desire to be thing and the latter by a desire for order and control often over one s circumstances or emotionsOne positive take away from the book is Hesse Biber s attitude towards weight or lack thereof The bias is towards culture and not towards the body Often in literature like this a fat phobic subcontext runs through the book undercutting the authors good intentions and honest attempt to understand the culture of thin See Emma WoolfThe book includes extensive notes and bibliography for each chapter which probably takes up a third of the book but it is clear where most findings come from that are not her own The Cult of Thinness is extensively referenced throughout academic literature and it is clear why I only hope that in her next edition she updates the Zombie stats

Summary Am I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of IdentityAm I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity

Read & Download Ö Am I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity Û PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Summary ´ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook º Sharlene Hesse-Biber Sharlene Hesse-Biber º 4 review Ative new way of understanding why women feel the way they do about their minds and bodies Specifically Hesse Biber highlights the various ways in which American families schools popular culture and the health and fitness industry all undermine young women's self confidence as they inculcate the notions that thinness is beauty and that a woman's body is important than her mind The author builds her case in part by letting her subjects tell their own story revealing in their own words how current standards of femininity lead many women to engage in eating habits that are not only self destructive but often akin to the obsessions and ritualistic behaviors found among members of cults For instance we meet Delia a bulimic college senior who makes the startling admission that my final affirmation of myself is how many guys look at me when I go into a bar We even learn of six year olds like Lauren already preoccupied wit. There are definitely a lot of interesting ideas to play with in this short and dense read uestions are articulated in a way that wouldn t have occurred to meThe mind body dichotomy described in which men and women are separated implicitly by the culture into mental faculties and physical characteristics respectively Its roots are traced as far back as Aristotle who posits that women are essentially soulless and evil and men pure and intellectual If the soul is really just the reification of a metaphysical concept the mind having a presence beyond the body then it s not far fetched to suggest that secular western culture could easily adapt this idea while shedding its superstitious origins Similarly the Christian view positioned women as wicked drawing men toward temptation If one thinks in terms of the mind body dichotomy where men would wish to shed their bodies in favor of the purely metaphysical unwelcome biological responses sexual urges would seem a hindrance to that ideal Except that they misidentified the source as something external as Christians often do the fucking devil made me do it In the passages offered Aristotle comes off as what would currently be regarded as an embittered nerd elevating his own strength for abstract thought though he was often completely off by denigrating those he was somehow preoccupied by love and hate both being passions Evolutionary biologists have made the case that prejudice is closer to human instinct than tolerance or egalitarianism Under this view our ancestors were suspicious first of those outside their families then outside their tribes and villages then those from other ethnicities other nations other ideologies and so on Is there something innate that also inclines a fear of otherness between gendersWhile a lot of interesting uestions are posed I wasn t satisfied that so much was attributed to society without also looking at the biological tendencies around which societies and cultures are formed For instance the common notion that men gain status directly through their accomplishments while women must do so through physical characteristics and only then indirectly through their attachment to a man It s fair to criticize the convention though both sexes are fairly trapped in their roles but they didn t develop in a vacuum There was no exalted architect for this One has consider when such things might have been natural and relevant and realize perhaps that it s only through the development of society that they ve been called into uestion It is to look at it from another angle not practical or utilitarian to be stronger than average in a culture disconnected from the process of finding food or fighting predators Obviously this was not always so and yet strength is still well regarded in spite of its growing irrelevance in many professions at least Maybe like racism it may not be instinctively natural to uestion gender ideals but it may be consciously possible There s also the uestion of the evolutionary imperative itself Though modern society has enabled people of a broader range of genetic fitness or adaptability to live longer and productively there may be traits that are uantitatively healthier and desirable from a genetic standpoint genetic cues being read unconsciously through pheromones facial symmetry etcThough I think the author fatuously implies a concerted effort to do this outside of the marketing realm she makes a solid case that the feminine ideal has been based upon the tastes of the men of a given time period and has evolved as such Their compliance being necessary to the indirect attainment of securitystatus within society And the trend has been literally narrowing the ideal to mathematical traits where beauty can be broken down to symmetry and proportions predictably and consistently Where nevertheless beautiful models fall below this ideal their images are manipulated to meet it This isn t new the painting Grande Odalisue by Jean Auguste Dominiue Ingres recently referenced in a Manic Street Preachers lyric portrayed a woman with an elongated back to suit the artist s aesthetic ideal What is new is the homogenization of the media across the country and around the world Now people are exposed to the same images and the sameness of those images is ever increasing while the disparity between the public and those images is also increasing eg the rise of obesity in western culture While it may be physically impossible to change one s build to match the ideal the dominance of western culture in other countries also confronts people of entirely different ethnicities with an even remote sense of what s attractive This puts people in a state of wrongness about which they can do nothing but repent buy shit as with concepts like Original Sin manipulative guilts that can never be uenchedAnd well this is good for industry too While the images are the product and there are products the images help sell the component of insecurity is also vital to the symbiotic relationship enjoyed by mass media junk food manufacturers diet weight loss elective surgery and self help markets Self loathing is profitable and so it s whether deliberately or not cultivated and profited from However the rise of eating disorders depression dysmorphia etc show that like petroleum and other natural resources there are limits the endurance of the human psyche and there s a point where it stops adapting and starts shutting down In response to this the problem is personalized by society and medicine the miserable person suffers from a disease and is DEFINITELY not responding to something in their environment But really it could be one or the other or maybe both It s hard to tell when there s a profit motive even treating it as an illness and a defense of the system itself in removing corporate responsibility from the euation A similar uestion is raised by Mark Ames s book Going Postal where possibly toxic exploitative and abusive workplaces go unexamined because it s easier marginalize the behavior of an individual than it is to look at what messy things might have influenced them Ultimately it s an indictment of the social irresponsibility of the capitalist system and its insatiable need to create unsustainable ways to move money around

Summary ´ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook º Sharlene Hesse-Biber

Read & Download Ö Am I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity Û PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Summary ´ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook º Sharlene Hesse-Biber Sharlene Hesse-Biber º 4 review Whether they are rich or poor tall or short liberal or conservative most young American women have one thing in common they want to be thin And they are willing to go to extraordinary lengths to get that way even to the point of starving themselves Why are America's women so preoccupied with weight What has caused record numbers of young women even before they reach their teenage years to suffer from anorexia and bulimia In Am I Thin Enough Yet Sharlene Hesse Biber answers these uestions and as she goes beyond traditional psychological explanations of eating disorders to level a powerful indictment against the social political and economic pressures women face in a weight obsessed societyPacked with first hand intimate portraits of young women from a wide variety of backgrounds and drawing on historical accounts and current material culled from both popular and scholarly sources Am I Thin Enough Yet offers a provoc. It was an okay book I discovered it in a humanities class when it was on the reading list I took it out from the library to read again It affected me on a personal level So many things in the book I could relate to I liked this book because it wasn t just about eating disorders it was about the context surrounding the drive to be thin and proposed the notion of a culture or a cult of thinnessI wished the book did Like someone said before there was nothing in the book that I didn t really know before But the bigger uestion I wished was answered was Why Why are girls dying to be thin even they know they re hurting themselves even though they know about the social historical context surrounding women s bodies Why do they keep playing into it Why do I keep playing into itMy Review of the book two years laterThe author has done extensive research and that is commendable Statements are supported by statistics and research studies and interviews and references are really thorough at the end of each chapterSo I applaud Hesse Biber s tireless research that went into this book This is the second time I ve read the book I was both shocked and apathetic The sheer amount of statistics made me apathetic It was like after a while I got so bored of reading the same sort of thing reiterated over and over again I was shocked that there are teachers out there who truly believe that chubby girls are stupid But when I thought about it again it suddenly twigged When I was a girl in primary school teachers riffed off of my weight Of course students did it but you kind of expected that when you were chubby Kids can be cruel But when teachers did it it had of an impact In grade 11 Physics my friend was feeling bad about her weight we had to use our own weights in the experimental calculations Anyhow my physics teacher who was really slender tall svelte told my friend not to feel bad because she had a lot of bulk and she tried to put a positive spin on it That she would want someone with a lot of bulk on her volleyball team This was a teacher that my friend highly respectedI was 16 then and my teacher was God and I never thought to uestion this interaction until years later How could she publicly comment on a teenage girl s weightbody type She didn t do it to be mean She honestly though there was nothing wrong with what she saidThe Culture of Thinness is insidious It permeates our culture ourselves entirelyIt explains why America is obsessed with a certain body type why culturally induced eating disorders emerge why America s obesity epidemic is surging why fad diets are so popular and the entire industry that is built on yo yo dietingIt creates this creates a circle where those who fit the ideal body type get to stay inside the circle and everyone else is cast outside The entire body industry fad diets weight loss supplements magazines new exercise euipment good foods vs bad foods is based on the attempts for those outside the circle to find their way back in And most of them can t thus explaining yo yo dietingIf Hesse Biber ever decides to write a third edition I hope she will expand the chapter on lesbiansgays straight men and racial minorities Hesse Biber is herself from a position of privilege I would like to see her expand the chapter by conducting extensive interviews with a large sample size of black women for example I fear that many of the things she has said are common assumptions For example I ve read that women of colour suffer from body image issues perhaps even than white women due to the social variables of race and maybe economic class This book is excellent from the viewpoint of white women but I would like to see diverse representation in terms of the research especiallyIn 2013 I gave this book 3 stars In 2015 I am giving this book 4 stars This book is fantastic but there is so much work to be done in terms of exploring the culture of whiteness and thinness